4 Following


Currently reading

MirrorMask (children's edition)
Neil Gaiman
The Unreal and the Real: Selected Stories, Volume One: Where on Earth
Ursula K. Le Guin
Betsy and Tacy Go Downtown
Maud Hart Lovelace
The Picture of Dorian Gray
Oscar Wilde, Camille Cauti
Riders of the Purple Sage
Zane Grey
Vampires, Zombies, & Wanton Souls
Marge Simon
Isabella's Garden - Glenda Millard, Rebecca Cool Isabella's Garden utilizes the same repetitious building pattern as The House That Jack Built and (at least to an extent) [b:Green Eggs and Ham|23772|Green Eggs and Ham|Dr. Seuss|http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1327875972s/23772.jpg|86934]. If Siggy's lukewarm reception is any indication, Glenda Millard and Rebecca Cool weren't quite as successful as these others. Why? Best I can tell, the folk art style didn't work for her. (Personally, I liked it!) As the story progresses, it gets wordier and wordier. Entire pages are crammed with text, limiting the artwork's ability to help tell the story. So at least in this instance, Isabella's Garden didn't have the advantage of toddler appeal. The book also held the dubious distinction of being the only one out of a batch of picture books from the library that was not requested for a reread.

Would the book be more successful with older children? Maybe, though the wordiness problem would persist. The focus on the cyclical journey of seeds is a neat idea though, and might be an effective tool for teaching environmental stewardship and sustainability to elementary schoolers. We'll see. Isabella's Garden might deserve another chance in a couple of years.